I’ve determined that I’m easily put off by empty advertising. If an ad is full of bright colours and loud noises but tells me next to nothing about the product in question, I tend to develop a poor opinion of said product. My attitude is that marketing should sell the tangible positives of the thing, not sell me a lifestyle connected to the thing.
Most days lately I feel like a cranky old person telling kids to get off my lawn.
Access to top titles is becoming increasingly hard to come by, especially in Canada where PR companies are being forced to work with smaller and smaller budgets while clients expect bigger returns. So we’re reliant on game trailers to tell us what a game is about, and what we should expect from it.
The thing is, game trailers tend to do a terrible job at that, and the follow up information from developers isn’t really much better. Secrecy is overvalued in gaming. Communication is given short shrift.
Most game trailers are expertly edited, decidedly exciting, and great promotion if games were films. However, they’re all starting to look very much the same. And they tell us very little about how a game plays, which is the single most important element of a video game. Since we know the game review system is seriously broken right now, and games are getting increasingly more expensive, it’s more important than ever that gamers know what they’re buying, but right now, they can only get that from Youtube Let’s Plays and Twitch streams which show them the actual game.
There has to be a happier, spoiler-free medium.
Game trailers should show the same “who, what, when, where, why and how” that articles about a game are expected to provide.
Who does the game appeal to? — With the cost of games climbing, I’m not going to buy another military shooter unless I think I’m going to get some sort of innovation. Other players want a strong community. Others still want a lot of gameplay hours. We’re so hung up on age, gender, and content rating that marketers are missing these other points.
What is it about? — “guys that shoot things” is an insufficient amount of detail. A film trailer is expected to give you the basics of what a film is about. Game trailers seem to forget that basic plot concept is extremely important for pulling in more casual gamers that TV ads will sway. Everyone tends to copy the original Gears of War marketing while missing the fact that those ads worked because they actually represented what the games were about: killing monsters and big bro feels.
When is it coming out? — I can’t get excited by a teaser trailer without a release date, since release dates are guesstimates at best these days anyway.
Where is it available? — This may sound like common sense, but many busy people can’t keep straight which games are console exclusives and which ones are multiplatform. Two seconds at the end of a trailer isn’t enough time for them to get that information.
Why is it worth buying this game? — It’s amazing, but this is the element a lot of mediocre game marketing misses in its attempts to be like every other piece of game marketing out there. That infamous Dead Space 2 campaign answered this question with “because your mom will hate it”… which I gotta admit would have swayed me at times when I was younger. The celebrity World of Warcraft ads reminded people to play Warcraft because it had transcended being a video game and had become a cultural reference. The why is the difference between an average ad and a great one.
How is this game going to be fun? — With the emphasis on seriousness in gaming right now, this point also gets missed a lot. It’s really not that hard to do, but I think a lot of companies miss that it’s important to do. For instance, the Overwatch ads show that you’ll have fun playing as a bright, colorful character shooting at other bright colorful characters. Sometimes it’s as simple as that. On the other hand, Xbox ran a big campaign for Rise of the Tomb Raider made the games look like Lara Croft movies. They didn’t make it clear that a big part of the fun was solving very interesting puzzles and taking down enemies. Too many ads make the game look very pretty, but kind of boring. Lara exploring a cave with a torch isn’t enough to hook most people. They need an emotional connection that gives them something to care about.
The sheer deluge of marketing this time of year is one of the reasons that the games press gets to cranky and apathetic. So give us a break, game marketers, and give us some information we can pass on to our viewers and readers. That’s much more important than another free t-shirt that rarely comes in the proper size anyway.